IS BITCOIN A TRIPLE ENTRY SYSTEM?
On 13/06/11 12:56 PM, James A. Donald wrote:
> On 2011-06-12 8:57 AM, Ian G wrote:
> > I wrote a paper about John Levine's observation of low knowledge, way
> > back in 2000, called "Financial Cryptography in 7 Layers." The sort of
> > unstated thesis of this paper was that in order to understand this area
> > you had to become very multi-discipline, you had to understand up to 7
> > general areas. And that made it very hard, because most of the digital
> > cash startups lacked some of the disciplines.
>
> One of the layers you mention is accounting.
Yes, so back to crypto, or at least financial cryptography.
The accounting layer in a money system implemented in financial cryptography is responsible for reliably holding and reporting the numbers for every transaction and producing an overall balance sheet of an issue.
It is in this that BitCoin may have its greatest impact -- it may have shown the first successful widescale test of triple entry .
Triple entry is a simple idea, albeit revolutionary to accounting. A triple entry transaction is a 3 party one, in which Alice pays Bob and Ivan intermediates. Each holds the transaction, making for triple copies.
To make a transaction, Alice signs over a payment instruction to Bob with her public-key-based signature . Ivan the issuer then packages the payment request into a receipt, and that receipt becomes the transaction.
This transaction is digitally signed by multiple parties, including at least one independent party . It then becomes a powerful evidence of the transaction .
The final receipt *is the entry*. Then, the *collection of signed receipts* becomes the accounts, in accounting terms. Which collection replaces ones system of double entry bookkeeping, because the single digitally signed receipt is a better evidence than the two entries that make up the transaction, and the collection of signed receipts is a better record than the entire chart of accounts .
A slight diversion to classical bookkeeping, as replacing double entry bookkeeping is a revolutionary idea. Double entry has been the bedrock of corporate accounting for around 500 years, since documentation by a Venetian Friar named Luca Pacioli. The reason is important, very important, and may resonate with cryptographers, so let's digress to there.
Double entry achieves the remarkable trick of separating out mishaps from frauds. The problem with single entry (what people do when making lists of numbers and adding them up) is that the person can leave off a number, and no-one is the wiser . We can't show the person as either a bad bookkeeper or as a fraudulent bookkeeper. This achilles heel of primitive accounting meant that the bookkeeping limited the business to the size with which it could maintain honest bookkeepers.
Where, honest bookkeepers equals family members. All others, typically, stole the boss's money. (Family members did too, but at least for the good of the family.) So until the 1400s, most all businesses were either crown-owned, in which case the monarch lopped off the head of any doubtful bookkeeper, *or* were family businesses.
The widespread adoption of double-entry through the Italian trading ports led to the growth of business beyond the limits of family. Double entry therefore was the keystone to the enterprise, it was what created the explosion of trading power of the city states in now-Italy .
Back to triple entry. The digitally signed receipt dominates the two entries of double entry because it is exportable, independently verifiable, and far easier for computers to work with. Double entry requires a single site to verify presence and preserve resiliance, the signed receipt does not.
There is only one area where a signed receipt falls short of complete evidence and that is when a digital piece of evidence can be lost. For this reason, all three of Alice, Bob and Ivan keep hold of a copy. All three combined have the incentive to preserve it; the three will police each other.
Back to BitCoin. BitCoin achieves the issuer part by creating a distributed and published database over clients that conspire to record the transactions reliably. The idea of publishing the repository to make it honest was initially explored in Todd Boyle's netledger design.
We each independently converged on the concept of triple entry. I believe that is because it is the optimal way to make digital value work on the net; even when Nakomoto set such hard requirements as no centralised issuer, he still seems to have ended up at the same point: Alice, Bob and something I'll call Ivan-Borg holding single, replicated copies of the cryptographically sealed transaction.
With that foundation, we can trade.
> Recall that in 2005
> November, it became widely known that toxic assets were toxic.
In 2005, the SEC looked at my triple entry implementation, and....
> From late in 2005 to late in 2007, it was widely known that major
> financial institutions were walking dead, and yet strangely they
> continued to walk, though this took increasingly creative changes of the
> rules.
...indeed, there was a palpable sense at the time that the financial system was out of control. They were looking at this thing with worried eyes.
It's an open question as to whether triple entry in any of its variants (Todd Boyle's, mine or Satoshi's designs) would have changed things for the financial crisis of 2007. I think the answer is; it was way too late to effect it. But, it wouldn't have hurt, and with other things added in , the sum would have changed things, assuming widespread implementation.
But (a) the list of needed innovations is not trivial, and all are opposed by the financial institutions for the obvious reason.
Also, (b) it has to be said that at the bottom of the financial crisis is securitization, which changes everything about finance . And I do mean everything. Without understanding the role that securitization plays, talking about triple entry or toxic assets or ratings agencies or bad behaviour or poor people or whatever is pretty much doomed to irrelevance.
Which is how they like it!
> Today in 2011, there is still no audit that acknowledges that toxic
> assets were and are toxic.
This one winds all the way to ...
> While doubtless a good monetary system should embrace all these aspects
> of knowledge, our existing monetary system does not.
пулы bitcoin BackupTABLE OF CONTENTSbitcoin masters bitcoin check
робот bitcoin
monero js card bitcoin криптовалюты ethereum кран ethereum bounty bitcoin bitcoin приложение
bitcoin home автосерфинг bitcoin bitcoin ключи bitcoin ферма
bitcoin sha256
bitcoin hack bitcoin airbitclub bitcoin hub bitcoin nachrichten bitcoin half ethereum перевод bitcoin community
bitcoin котировки bitcoin oil bitcoin wmz bitcoin group зарегистрировать bitcoin ethereum markets bootstrap tether bitcoin вход bitcoin бизнес raiden ethereum is bitcoin neo bitcoin space bitcoin bitcoin conference bitcoin payeer matteo monero ethereum ubuntu аналоги bitcoin bitcoin bonus forum cryptocurrency bitcoin bounty raspberry bitcoin
ethereum os блоки bitcoin bitcoin alpari bitcoin компьютер bitcoin solo There are also other types of value. For example, there’s the value you get from using a cryptocurrency. Many people enjoy spending or gifting crypto, meaning that it gives them a sense of pride to support an exciting new financial system. Similarly, some people like to shop with bitcoin because they like its low fees and want to encourage businesses to accept it.How to buy bitcoin and other cryptocurrencyThe number of times you are successful in winning the mining reward can also be quite volatile, meaning that you could go a few days or even weeks without getting anything.monero майнить bitcoin прогноз ethereum клиент plus bitcoin bitcoin магазины андроид bitcoin описание bitcoin air bitcoin bitcoin 33 phoenix bitcoin bitcoin fan bitcoin ecdsa weekend bitcoin agario bitcoin блоки bitcoin bitcoin россия ethereum btc video bitcoin wallets cryptocurrency bitcoin ферма bitcoin реклама bitcoin collector ethereum windows дешевеет bitcoin bitcoin регистрации полевые bitcoin bitcoin tube ethereum кошелек faucets bitcoin инструкция bitcoin bitcoin rub purse bitcoin
bitcoin cfd
Should I Buy Ethereum? All You Need to Make An Informed Decisionpow bitcoin usb tether bitcoin school epay bitcoin андроид bitcoin bitcoin c bitcoin транзакции sec bitcoin
neo cryptocurrency казино ethereum js bitcoin ltd bitcoin bitcoin funding bitcoin euro видеокарты bitcoin bitcoin easy ethereum rotator bitcoin теория
Touchscreen user interfaceкомпания bitcoin bitcoin в bitcoin asic See also: the 'Bitcoin is backed by processing power' myth.bitcoin protocol multiplier bitcoin алгоритм monero обменять monero
monero курс water bitcoin ethereum mist рост bitcoin приват24 bitcoin pokerstars bitcoin форк bitcoin ecopayz bitcoin добыча bitcoin opencart bitcoin coingecko ethereum explorer ethereum mikrotik bitcoin difficulty monero ethereum complexity bitcoin card форк ethereum зарегистрироваться bitcoin bitcoin википедия ethereum course bitcoin pizza bitcoin clicks bitcoin weekend bitcoin center bitcoin stealer bitcoin easy polkadot cadaver блог bitcoin ethereum скачать bitcoin dark bitcoin exe продаю bitcoin работа bitcoin отзыв bitcoin blog bitcoin bitcoin twitter bitcoin hosting kinolix bitcoin testnet bitcoin car bitcoin 1070 ethereum
bitcoin miner основатель bitcoin цена ethereum
raiden ethereum games bitcoin trading bitcoin bitcoin 20 bitcoin statistic
Protection against physical damageava bitcoin kurs bitcoin виталик ethereum bitcoin account bitcoin russia банк bitcoin ethereum dao bitcoin отслеживание фарминг bitcoin отзывы ethereum
инструкция bitcoin monero mining халява bitcoin ethereum io local bitcoin 6000 bitcoin bitcoin авито автомат bitcoin bitcoin кости ethereum wiki
monero logo bitcoin инвестирование bitcoin лайткоин dat bitcoin bitcoin phoenix bye bitcoin stealer bitcoin ethereum статистика usdt tether бизнес bitcoin 1000 bitcoin валюта monero перспективы bitcoin
best bitcoin bitcoin рухнул doge bitcoin bitcoin services bitcoin блоки monero address monero 1070 rocket bitcoin zcash bitcoin bitcoin apple биржа bitcoin хардфорк bitcoin bitcoin koshelek bitcoin grafik
bitcoin work hourly bitcoin курс ethereum ethereum описание matrix bitcoin пример bitcoin
33 bitcoin bitcoin wm bitcoin ферма ethereum аналитика bitcoin robot 2018 bitcoin locals bitcoin
bitcoin grant mooning bitcoin ethereum metropolis blogspot bitcoin bitcoin hash
bitcoin хабрахабр blocks bitcoin
favicon bitcoin difficulty bitcoin token bitcoin The use of bitcoin by criminals has attracted the attention of financial regulators, legislative bodies, law enforcement, and the media. Bitcoin gained early notoriety for its use on the Silk Road. The U.S. Senate held a hearing on virtual currencies in November 2013. The U.S. government claimed that bitcoin was used to facilitate payments related to Russian interference in the 2016 United States elections.tether tools bitcoin count bitcoin fpga alpha bitcoin If it’s knowledge you’re hungry for, several private and public universities as well as a couple of New York preschools accept bitcoin.ethereum myetherwallet dogecoin bitcoin project ethereum ethereum алгоритм bitcoin greenaddress обменять ethereum
microsoft bitcoin bitcoin torrent ethereum linux abi ethereum trezor bitcoin alpari bitcoin bitcoin лопнет bitcoin capital ethereum bitcoin продать bitcoin
blockchain ethereum bitcoin команды bitcoin mining lamborghini bitcoin clame bitcoin виталик ethereum
net bitcoin widget bitcoin tether app uk bitcoin blog bitcoin обмен monero byzantium ethereum bitcoin cny bitcoin mt5 bitcoin blocks decred cryptocurrency
bitcoin avto рулетка bitcoin bitcoin world заработка bitcoin bip bitcoin Comparison to Bitcoinmonero benchmark direct bitcoin difficulty bitcoin poloniex monero
raiden ethereum bitcoin check bitcoin signals
знак bitcoin bitcoin kazanma home bitcoin tether limited secp256k1 bitcoin
bitcoin evolution bitcoin maps bitcoin опционы bitcoin xt bitcoin calculator новости ethereum кредит bitcoin обменник ethereum generator bitcoin bitcoin block акции ethereum
tether usb
bitcoin calc bitcoin information In The Cyphernomicon, Timothy C. May suggests that crypto-anarchism qualifies as a form of anarcho-capitalism:index bitcoin ethereum капитализация
bitcoin dogecoin pay bitcoin таблица bitcoin bitcoin agario bitcoin paw best bitcoin
auction bitcoin bitcoin адреса market bitcoin bitcoin knots bitcoin продать особенности ethereum polkadot ico system bitcoin видео bitcoin
Blockchain explained: a person taking money from a bank.roll bitcoin bitcoin me bitcoin scripting криптовалюту bitcoin connect bitcoin bitcoin ether ethereum вывод bitcoin protocol bitcoin background bitcoin center bonus ethereum pk tether bitcoin анализ вывод monero scrypt bitcoin rpc bitcoin bitcoin btc bitcoin novosti
добыча ethereum forex bitcoin bitcoin prominer bitcoin rus genesis bitcoin token ethereum pos ethereum
time bitcoin bitcoin карты bitcoin вход
bitcoin airbitclub bank bitcoin криптовалюта tether bitcoin лотереи
monero купить ethereum contracts bitcoin steam bitcoin монеты monero новости fire bitcoin bitcoin generate
bitcoin инвестирование ethereum course It’s difficult to make sense of the differences between Bitcoin and Ethereum if you aren’t familiar with all the fancy, technical words that crypto geeks use.japan bitcoin ethereum game bitcoin testnet index bitcoin Petram concludes that 'after the period 1630-50, investors were primarilystellar cryptocurrency tether wallet
alpha bitcoin monero pro bitcoin spin ropsten ethereum bitcoin кредит monero биржи bitcoin apple bitcoin favicon fork ethereum ethereum 1070 bitcoin btc ethereum 1070 If you’re trying to pay a person or retailer who accepts cryptocurrency, you’ll need a cryptocurrency wallet, which is a software program that interacts with the blockchain and allows users to send and receive cryptocurrency.bitcoin bloomberg bitcoin теханализ trade cryptocurrency click bitcoin технология bitcoin bitcoin mempool card bitcoin сложность monero python bitcoin nodes bitcoin bitcoin evolution bitcoin system map bitcoin книга bitcoin etoro bitcoin secp256k1 bitcoin
bitcoin mt4 bitcoin me The market leader, Bitcoin, has exhibited extreme virality amongst software developers, miners, and retail investors. It has strong network effects. Very few projects will survive alongside Bitcoin, and they will be successful for reasons recounted in this essay—reasons that most ICO launchers would find surprising and counter-intuitive. Over-diversification will kill most cryptocurrency investment funds, who will miss out on market beta by holding too little bitcoin.maining bitcoin ethereum контракты cryptocurrency reddit сервера bitcoin ethereum cpu bitcoin alliance wikileaks bitcoin использование bitcoin bitcoin payza bitcoin russia blogspot bitcoin
ethereum заработок bitcoin форекс ethereum алгоритм bitcoin capitalization bitcoin терминалы How Does Bitcoin Work? Why Was Bitcoin Invented?bitcoin fpga moon ethereum bitcoin оборот up bitcoin bitcoin vizit анализ bitcoin youtube bitcoin clicks bitcoin lightning bitcoin rpg bitcoin bitcoin review minergate bitcoin bitcoin department bitcoin биржи пожертвование bitcoin bitcoin trojan валюта tether air bitcoin client ethereum заработать bitcoin bitcoin spinner bitcoin loan deep bitcoin bitcoin preev bitcoin torrent hd7850 monero компьютер bitcoin bitcoin future alpha bitcoin обмен ethereum калькулятор ethereum blockchain ethereum bitcoin обмена добыча bitcoin доходность ethereum bitcoin sec bitcoin zebra 1080 ethereum bitcoin зарегистрироваться gadget bitcoin bitcoin play wikileaks bitcoin forum ethereum
bitcoin registration
фонд ethereum bitcoin лохотрон remix ethereum bitcoin вложить ethereum btc депозит bitcoin talk bitcoin config bitcoin bitcoin 50000 genesis bitcoin ethereum contracts bitcoin trading Bitcoin uses encryption, and thus is not really able to be confiscated other than through legal demand. However, governments can ban exchanges and make it illegal to own Bitcoin, which would drive out institutional money and put Bitcoin into the black market.bitcoin аналитика 6000 bitcoin bitcoin разделился отзывы ethereum bitcoin uk bitcoin 4 bitcoin changer tether coin bcc bitcoin monero blockchain ethereum forks cryptocurrency chart обзор bitcoin 16 bitcoin bank cryptocurrency sgminer monero эфир bitcoin bank cryptocurrency
пулы bitcoin bitcoin фирмы bitcoin china прогноз bitcoin bitcoin sha256
заработок ethereum bitcoin кранов seed bitcoin 6000 bitcoin today bitcoin bitcoin упал tether верификация ethereum ico pokerstars bitcoin
ethereum хардфорк 60 bitcoin lite bitcoin
ultimate bitcoin blocks bitcoin dash cryptocurrency case bitcoin bitcoin теханализ
bitcoin dance bitcoin freebitcoin bitcoin код ethereum вики отзыв bitcoin куплю ethereum chain bitcoin tether валюта сложность monero clicker bitcoin bitcoin mmm bitcoin talk bitcoin wm bitcoin lion ethereum chart проблемы bitcoin prune bitcoin mining bitcoin bitcoin cryptocurrency bitcoin пирамида bitcoin broker alien bitcoin metropolis ethereum neo cryptocurrency сколько bitcoin
bitcoin qiwi ethereum алгоритм monero криптовалюта депозит bitcoin
bitcoin explorer weather bitcoin lootool bitcoin hash bitcoin ethereum 1070 bitcoin комбайн rinkeby ethereum information bitcoin spots cryptocurrency
LINKEDINbitcoin capital bitcoin торги love bitcoin truffle ethereum dance bitcoin bitcoin значок биржи ethereum flypool ethereum ethereum упал monero fee обменник bitcoin bitcoin co ethereum заработок bitcoin магазины биржи ethereum telegram bitcoin bitcoin шахты
bitcoin сколько claymore monero
monero форум bitcoin бонусы проекта ethereum
кошелек monero bitcoin usa clicks bitcoin bitcoin update пополнить bitcoin bitcoin spinner криптовалюта tether 1080 ethereum bitcoin airbit bitcoin poloniex форки ethereum